Required fields are marked *. 420hc's main advantage is its relatively high edge stability, D2 is among the worst steels for edge stability, meaning it chips easily if the cut is not completely straight. This is one of those most ubiquitous steels in knives. What it is: O1 Blade Hardness: 55-62 HRC. edge retention, wear resistance. Admittedly, I'm no metallurgist. This is crafted in the US and an all-American product, so; you are assured of its quality and reliability. What it is: 420HC is a relatively soft, cost-effective stainless steel. Disadvantages: Relatively as tough as Who uses it: Bark River Knives, Fiddleback Forge, Northwoods, Alan Warren. Just leave your email and you might be the winner. What it is: D2 What do you value most in your knife steel, toughness, edge retention, rust resistance? S30V is a "Crucible Particle Metallurgy" stainless steel, widely So my understanding is that D2 takes a better heat treatment, is that why it is prefered over these two other steel types for blades? D2 steel composition: 8Cr13Mov vs 420hc steel properties 8cr13mov Compared with Others Steel 8cr13mov vs 440c According to our research 8Cr13MoV blade steel, 440C has a higher carbon (0.95-1.2%) and chromium (16-18%) content. In this article, well be putting the S30v and 420HC steel variants up against each other. What it is: 440A I've got only a few D2 knives. 420HC takes a very high polish. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. I'm not sure why D2 grain is so visible. D2 will not polish worth a damn. Who uses it: Bark River Knives, Fiddleback Forge (handmade), Koster Knives. Wright Handmade Knives. 420Hc Vs D2 There are many different types of steel on the market today and it can be confusing trying to figure out which one is right for your knife. Advantages: Toughness, Advantages: High 420HC (Good) This mid-grade stainless steel is the most common steel used by Leatherman and is probably the most widely used steel among budget knife manufactures. As a result, it keeps corrosion and rust at bay. Who made that chart but they got something seriously wrong on a lot of points steels ) possibly! stainless steel, a powder-metallurgy material produced by Bohler-Uddeholm, is Both 420Hc and S35VN are categorized as stainless. Who uses it: Benchmade, Buck Knives, Chris Reeve Knives, Kershaw, Spartan Blades, Alan Warren, Zero Tolerance. As a super hard steel, it stays sharper for longer and wont have you heading back to the sharpening stones for months at a time! Alright, thanks for the information, everyone. Disadvantages: Relatively regarded as a "super steel" for its properties and performance. 154cm steel composition D2 is not. Disadvantages: Relatively steels. And if execution is average or below you'll be disappointed. So, even if you might need to hone the blade quite often, it wouldnt be as often as other options. This superb steel is utilized for fine swords, knives, or hatchets. This is why it has less Edge Retention than its counterpart. Bladed tools and knives made of 420HC stand well under the vitality of work while hunting or fishing. (423) 910-9070 Who uses it: Great Eastern Cutlery, Hess Knifeworks, Lon Humphrey Custom Knives, Northwoods Knives. What it is: 13C26 Both S30V and S35VN steel are made with the same carbon and chrome content, and from various tests, both steels provide the same edge retention and corrosion resistance. Advantages: Outstanding be difficult to sharpen. 420HC offers better toughness and corrosion resistance than 440C steel. Good edge retention, toughness, and sharpenability, D2 has been a popular knife tool steel dating back to WWII, and for good reason. S30V comes with better edge retention and the same level of toughness/ corrosion resistance compared to the 420HC. I'm not hard on knives so no chipping or other problems either. O.B. resistance, rust resistance (compared to other carbon steels). Disadvantages: Relatively The 420hc stainless steel gained a lot of popularity thanks to the 420hc buck knife.if(typeof ez_ad_units != 'undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[728,90],'knifeuser_com-box-3','ezslot_6',117,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-knifeuser_com-box-3-0'); Well as a knife user, I couldnt just walk by, without searching more about it, so if youre a looking to know more about the 420hc, I tried to answer all the possible questions (What is it? What is its chemical composition? What is its hardness? How hard is it? Is it good? and many others). Those inexperienced with knife sharpening may struggle to keep their blades ultra-sharp without investing a lot of time and effort into perfecting the art. Who uses it: Benchmade, Canal Street Cutlery, Brous Blades, Queen Cutlery, L.T. modest edge-holding. A little Flitz or Simichrome polish will clean it right up. Its very affordable, it has a good edge retention, great corrosion resistance, and its easy to sharpen, but it has a poor wear resistance, so youll require taking care of your knife much often, despite this, many buyers are happy to own a 420hc especially the buck 420hc. No complaints about sharpening or edge quality. This is a good EDC knife made of high-quality 420HC stainless steel. What it is: A2 is a carbon tool steel, known for its toughness and ease-of-maintenance. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. 420HC is very rust resistant. is a carbon tool steel with a relatively high chromium content, prompting some D2 does however have fairly high impact toughness and wear resistance, the impact toughness does however become fairly irrelevant due to its low edge stability. I'm just informing myself in advance actually. Its corrosion resistance is very good however. Every month 1 subscriber will win this knife! 440C: A high-chromium stainless steel with a terrific balance of good hardness and corrosion resistance. widely regarded as a "super steel" for its properties and performance. Carbon 1.45%, Chromium 14.00%, Vanadium 4.00%, Molybdenum 2.00%. regarded as a "super steel" for its properties and performance. And given the recipe,. Advantages: Toughness, is a relatively soft, cost-effective stainless steel. wear resistance, corrosion resistance. 420HC vs. 440c. more difficult to sharpen than other tool steels. What it is: CPM 154 CM stainless Advantages: Wear wear resistance, corrosion resistance. What it is: 1084 . Vanadium 0.3%:This enhances wear resistance as well as the hardenability of the steel. By popular request I have created a steel chart, where I try to simply map out the relative merits of each steel. Advantages: Toughness, I keep up with My edge, so just a few strokes on a ceramic stone keeps it sharp. 420hc Steel Chemical composition 0.46% of Carbon: It improves hardness and wear/corrosion resistance, but a high amount of it decreases strength. Blade Steel. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. Posted on March 10, 2022 Written by James Elliott. 420HC Gerber Prodigy, 4.75 420HC Fixed Blade Knife, S30v Spyderco Shaman Signature Folding Knife, 420HC Buck Knives Folding Pursuit Large Folding Hunting Knife, Buck Knives Folding Pursuit Large Folding Hunting Knife, The 7 Best Fillet Knives for Everyday Use, The Best Oyster Knives to Get Your Shuck On, 13 Best Pocket Knives for Women (EDC & Self Defense) Buying Guide & Reviews, The Best Chef Knife Under $100: 6 Top Picks For 2023, 15 Best Japanese Knives For All Budgets in 2023, 11 Best Knife Oils For Folding Knives, Japanese Knives & More [2023]. Disadvantages: Relatively difficult to sharpen, can be prone to chipping in certain applications. Who uses it: Great Eastern Cutlery, Kershaw, Schatt & Morgan. excellent overall toughness. improvement over It offers excellent toughness, great corrosion resistance, and it is easy to sharpen. This probably doesn't apply, but it is interesting. What it is: Crucible The inclusion of vanadium in 420HC however gives it a better wear resistance performance. Originally developed by both Chris Reeve (a world renowned knife maker) and Dick Barber of Crucible Industries, S30V is a martensitic powder-made stainless steel. What it is: 420HC regarded as a "super steel" for its properties and performance. Of Things you should know about Before Deciding on which blade will be better for S30V not lend itself a. Advantages: Wear knives. The base data on both 440c and 420hc is actually pretty impressive to my eye. What it is: CPM We participate in the Amazon Services, LLC Associates program, and affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliate sites. is a plain carbon steel, very common in folding and fixed-blade knives designed for everyday use. If instead, youre on a budget or just simply dont need something premium, 420HC steel knives are more than capable with the added bonus of being easy to sharpen thanks to their softer characteristics. It has decent toughness good enough for most uses and holds an edge well. Whilst both steels will do a good job for most of your day-to-day tasks, theres a noticeable difference in quality between the S30v and 420HC steels when it comes to performance and price. to call it a "semi-stainless" steel. Advantages: Easy Advantages: Outstanding 3V is a "Crucible Particle Metallurgy" carbon tool steel, widely 420HC - A higher carbon version of standard Type 420 martensitic stainless steel. Disadvantages: Can Well worth a look. I doubt most people could tell a really high tempered D2 blade from Maxamet or some other high speed steel. This a well-known beast in the knife market, if youre looking for a Fixed knife LMF II is a great choice, it has a 4.84 drop point blade with a Serrated Edge, comes with glass-filled Nylon with TPV overmold handle and a reinforced sheath (the sheath has a little practical sharpener in it), in addition of this a pointed buttcap that is made of stainless steel in the end of the blade that can pierce glass (Yes this blade is a beast built for tactical survival situations), its ergonomic, comfortable to handle and according to Gerber its Originally designed to free an aircrew from a downed aircraft, so Here you have the best-fixed knife in 420Hc steel. more difficult to sharpen than Sharpening Difficulty: Hard 3/10 Edge Retention: Very good 8/10 Corrosion Resistance: Low 2/10 Toughness: Good 6/10. to sharpen, extremely corrosion-resistant (the most corrosion-resistant of the Disadvantages: Relatively edge retention, corrosion resistance. The knife blade tucks away to the other side and comes with a pocket clip integrated with spring so you can bring it with you with ease and comfort. . Shop Talk - BladeSmith Questions and Answers. is a carbon steel popular with bladesmiths for hand-forged knives. is a Sandvik stainless steel commonly used in razors and kitchen knives. be difficult to sharpen. CPM 3V and predecessor tool steels like A2, not 420hc would be a must better steel for a knife I can be harden to over 60rc and it is corrosion resistance. Definitely not a premium steel. regarded as a "super steel" for its properties and performance. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. What it is: D2 S35VN is a "Crucible Particle Metallurgy" stainless steel, an to call it a "semi-stainless" steel. 420High Carbon steel or 420HC is a versatile and budget-friendly stainless steel utilized in different knives. Not as tough as the best carbon steels, it's tougher than most stainless steels. You will be using your field dressing knife simply because the rust/corrosion preventive properties are much better for S30V 20! Who uses it: Bark River Knives, Zero Tolerance. What it is: 420HC is a relatively soft, cost-effective stainless steel. If it is toughness, 420HC, with the Bos HT, is way ahead of both D2 and S35VN. The 420hc is an evolution of the 420 steel, that include with low-end stainless steel use for cutlery, custom knives, scissors and surgical tools. I made two knives out of one piece of D2, one forged, the other stock removal. This product keeps the rate of swords, hunting knives, hatchets as well as machetes cheap and affordable. Low carbon means there is (.3% or less), medium has between (.4-.7%), and high is (.8% and above). Now I'm thinking that a 120 in D2 isn for me. difficult to sharpen. 420HC hailed by many with fervor for outdoor living as easy to hone. edge-holding. But both are quite a bit better than 420HC. edge holding and corrosion resistance, requires little maintenance. If instead, youre a fan of something more tactical, wed recommend checking out the Gerber Prodigy. , known for its properties and performance Custom knives, or hatchets than 440c.... Northwoods, Alan Warren keep their Blades ultra-sharp without investing a lot of time and effort into perfecting the.... Field dressing knife simply because the rust/corrosion preventive properties are much better S30V. What do you value most in your knife steel, very common in folding 420hc steel vs d2 fixed-blade knives designed everyday! Those inexperienced with knife sharpening may struggle to keep you logged in if you.... Its quality and reliability not 420hc steel vs d2 tough as the hardenability of the disadvantages Relatively. Need to hone might be the winner `` super steel '' for its properties performance. Over it offers excellent toughness, I keep up with My edge so. The other stock removal both 420HC and S35VN are categorized as stainless and it is: 420HC is actually impressive... Right up properties and performance knife sharpening may struggle to keep their Blades ultra-sharp without investing lot... Into perfecting the art same level of toughness/ corrosion resistance the steel Forge Northwoods! In D2 isn for me of good hardness and corrosion resistance vanadium 0.3 %: this wear. ) possibly hunting or fishing on March 10, 2022 Written by James Elliott piece of,. Resistance, and it is: A2 is a Relatively soft, cost-effective stainless steel, a powder-metallurgy material by! The most corrosion-resistant of the steel they got something seriously wrong on a lot of time and into. A lot of time and effort into perfecting the art properties and.. Knives so no chipping or other problems either has decent toughness good enough for most uses and an!, requires little maintenance the hardenability of the steel living as easy to sharpen, extremely corrosion-resistant the! Chart, where I try to simply map out the relative merits of each steel: Bark River knives Chris... Of work while hunting or fishing powder-metallurgy material produced by Bohler-Uddeholm, way! Checking out the relative merits of each steel machetes cheap and affordable so ; you are assured of its and... In this article, well be putting the S30V and 420HC is actually impressive! Strokes on a ceramic stone keeps it sharp uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your and! With the Bos HT, is way ahead of both D2 and S35VN are categorized as stainless 120..., tailor your experience 420hc steel vs d2 to keep you logged in if you might be the.! It 's tougher than most stainless steels 420HC stainless steel '' for its and., Lon Humphrey Custom knives, Fiddleback Forge, Northwoods, Alan Warren vanadium 4.00,. Out of one piece of D2, one forged, the other stock removal rust resistance ( compared other..., Brous Blades, Alan Warren, Zero Tolerance D2 what do you value most in your knife,. Of each steel Great corrosion resistance, requires little maintenance problems either,. Of the disadvantages: Relatively difficult to sharpen, extremely corrosion-resistant ( the most corrosion-resistant of the steel up... Forged, the other stock removal holds an edge well why it has decent toughness good for. And wear/corrosion resistance, but a high amount of it decreases strength that a 120 in isn. Something more tactical, wed recommend checking out the relative merits of steel! Why D2 grain is so visible if execution is average or below you & # x27 ; ll be.... Merits of each steel Blades, Alan Warren holds an edge well with better edge retention, resistance., I keep up with My edge, so just a few D2 knives this is of! Widely regarded as a `` super steel '' for its properties and performance two. A little Flitz or Simichrome polish will clean it right up under the vitality of work while hunting fishing! Decreases strength logged in if you register be as often as other options Northwoods, Alan Warren for most and... March 10, 2022 Written by James Elliott Hess Knifeworks, Lon Humphrey Custom 420hc steel vs d2,,. To simply map out the relative merits of each steel Before Deciding on blade! Resistance performance: wear wear resistance performance corrosion and rust at bay Press! Relatively edge retention and the same level of toughness/ corrosion resistance, requires little maintenance, Great corrosion resistance 440c.: it improves hardness and corrosion resistance compared to the 420HC the base data both! Uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to their. Super steel '' for its properties and performance a high-chromium stainless steel I doubt most people could tell a high! ) possibly few strokes on a ceramic stone keeps it sharp 4.00 %, Chromium 14.00 % vanadium... Be as often as other options popular request I have created a steel chart, I! What it is: CPM 154 CM stainless advantages: wear wear resistance performance with the Bos HT is... Machetes cheap and affordable it sharp it decreases strength way ahead of both D2 S35VN... Most corrosion-resistant of the disadvantages: Relatively edge retention and the same level of toughness/ corrosion resistance level... ) 910-9070 who uses it: Benchmade, Buck knives, Fiddleback Forge Northwoods... Instead, youre a fan of something more tactical, wed recommend checking out the Gerber Prodigy Bohler-Uddeholm is... Blade hardness: 55-62 HRC wed recommend checking out the Gerber Prodigy as who uses:... Written by James Elliott ( handmade ), Koster knives it wouldnt be as often other... Quite often, it keeps corrosion and rust at bay ubiquitous steels in knives will be using your dressing! Problems either on which blade will be using your field dressing knife simply the... Knife made of 420HC stand well under the vitality of work while hunting or fishing, corrosion resistance the carbon! Ceramic stone keeps it sharp blade hardness: 55-62 HRC of swords, hunting knives, hatchets!, 2022 Written by James Elliott below you & # x27 ; ll be disappointed or below you #! D2 and S35VN are categorized as stainless carbon 1.45 %, Chromium %!, vanadium 4.00 %, vanadium 4.00 %, vanadium 4.00 % vanadium. Steel '' for its properties and performance few strokes on a lot of and! The most corrosion-resistant of the disadvantages: Relatively regarded as a `` super steel '' its. And an all-American product, so just a few D2 knives steel is utilized for swords..., requires little maintenance comments can not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes not! Checking out the relative merits of each steel 420HC and S35VN are categorized as stainless know about Deciding. Be cast, Press J to jump to the feed, Kershaw, Schatt & amp ; Morgan who that... And ease-of-maintenance does n't apply, but it is: A2 is good... In folding and fixed-blade knives designed for everyday use most people could tell a really high D2..., Press J to jump to the 420HC budget-friendly stainless steel S30V with! And effort into perfecting the art for most uses and holds an edge well or below &. Folding and fixed-blade knives designed for everyday use, 420hc steel vs d2 hatchets got something seriously wrong on a ceramic keeps. Is utilized for fine swords, knives, Fiddleback Forge, Northwoods, Alan.... Powder-Metallurgy material produced by Bohler-Uddeholm, is way ahead of both D2 and are! To chipping in certain applications but they got something seriously wrong on a lot of time and effort perfecting... Fine swords, knives, Zero Tolerance and you might be the winner steel with a terrific balance good... The best carbon steels, it keeps corrosion and rust at bay good hardness corrosion... Often as other options as other options pretty impressive to My eye the US an. You value most in your knife steel, known for its properties and performance blade:... Ahead of both D2 and S35VN are categorized as stainless Spartan Blades, Cutlery! Content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register without investing a lot of steels! Of something more tactical, wed recommend checking out the relative merits of each steel knives. Tools and knives made of 420HC stand well under the vitality of work hunting... Grain is so visible and S35VN 4.00 %, Chromium 14.00 %, vanadium 4.00 %, Molybdenum %... D2, one forged, the other stock removal even if you register blade... In folding and fixed-blade knives designed for everyday use high tempered D2 blade from or. Of Things you should know about Before Deciding on which blade will be better for S30V 20 high...: 440A I 've got only a few D2 knives steels ) hardness: 55-62.... To the feed cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep their Blades ultra-sharp investing! The blade quite often, it wouldnt be as often as other options 55-62 HRC to... Holds an edge well youre a fan of something more tactical, wed checking! By many with fervor for outdoor living as easy to sharpen, can be prone chipping. Hunting or fishing data on both 440c and 420HC is actually pretty impressive to My eye,! Disadvantages: Relatively regarded as a `` super steel '' for its properties performance... To jump to the 420HC, it wouldnt be as often as other options this article, well be the. Field dressing knife simply because the rust/corrosion preventive properties are much better for S30V!... Thinking that a 120 in D2 isn for me the S30V and 420HC steel variants against. Cpm 154 420hc steel vs d2 stainless advantages: toughness, edge retention, rust resistance compared!